I actually have a degree in History, so I was really looking forward to the Historian badge. Doing the badge has reminded me how much I love studying history and how much I miss reading around topics, weighing the evidence and coming to my own conclusions.
Understand the difference between a primary and secondary source.
A primary source is an authentic source with direct access to the time period or experience: e.g. letters, documents, wills, photographs, paintings, diaries.
A secondary source is one that is removed from firsthand experience in some way: e.g. a textbook or a book written by an historian.
Primary sources tend to be raw data, while secondary sources are usually interpretations of that data.
Compare and contrast two or more perspectives of the same historical event.
I have chosen to look at the events in India in 1857, commonly called the Indian Mutiny but also known as the Great Rebellion, the Revolt of 1857, the Indian Insurrection, and the First War of Independence. These events played out as an uprising against the rule of the British East India Company.
The traditional explanation for the mutiny is that new rifle cartridges were introduced in early 1857, believed by infantrymen (sepoys) to have been greased by cow and pig fat, which was insulting to Hindus and Muslims respectively. As a result, the soldiers rebelled against their officers.
I read three books on the topic:
Saul David, The Indian Mutiny, Penguin, 2002
Julian Spilsbury, The Indian Mutiny, Phoenix, 2007
William Dalrymple, The Last Mughal, Bloomsbury, 2009
Saul David’s work explores the causes of, and progress of, the mutiny as it developed throughout India. He suggests that the causes of the mutiny were primarily economic, professional and political. The British East India Company had recently taken over more or less every territory, culminating in the annexation of Oudh, from which a large proportion of the Bengal Army came. David suggests that many soldiers would have preferred to go back to the old days of war and plunder, where they had the chance of becoming rich by collecting spoils of war. The British also lacked understanding of local rules and traditions of land ownership.
David argues that mutineers wanted to replace their colonial overlords with traditional Indian rulers, mainly because they thought service to these new overlords would be more rewarding. There was also widespread dissatisfaction with uniform, housing and pay. He remarks that older soldiers were most likely to remain loyal, because they had more to lose – such as their pension.
However, he also suggests that a change in the relationship between the British and Indians helped to contribute to the rebellion, arguing that soldiers were more likely to mutiny if they didn’t have a longstanding, respected officer as leader. When the British first came to India, they often integrated into society, taking Indian wives and mistresses and embracing local culture. In more recent years, a division had become more apparent: for instance, many British officials now married before arriving in India, and with their white wives and families remained aloof from local customs, even looking down on them.
Julian Spilbury’s thoughts are along similar lines to David’s. He points out the British soldiers’ increasing distance from Indian troops. The conquest of Oudh meant that sepoys lost the right of petition in the courts to the British Resident at Lucknow, a privilege which they greatly valued. Once the Sikhs of the Punjab had been defeated, the last independent nation state in the area had gone, and sepoys feared that they would be sent overseas – something that high-caste Hindus in particular feared. Victory also meant a pay cut for the soldiers, as they were no longer entitled to extra allowances once Scinde and the Punjab became British provinces.
Spilsbury does touch on possible religious reasons for the uprising. The growing evangelical lobby in Parliament meant that missionaries were sent to India in increasing numbers, and there was a fear among Indians that they were going to be forcibly converted to Christianity.
William Dalrymple’s work is different from the others because he doesn’t draw on only English sources. In his research he used Persian and Urdu documents relating to Delhi in 1857, known as the Mutiny Papers, from the National Archives of India. He also uses plenty of other sources which expose the brutality of the British response to the uprising (English-language sources tend to focus on the atrocities committed against the British).
Dalrymple, in common with Spilsbury, argues that the growing disconnect between the British and Indians helped to fuel the uprising. He suggests that the British became increasingly arrogant as they had defeated their Indian rivals as well as the French.
He also emphasises the religious reasons for the revolt: the growth of evangelical Christianity and the plans to impose Christianity on Muslims and Hindus. He argues that the mutiny was primarily a war of religion, as well as a more generalised desire for freedom from foreign domination. He notes that participants cited religious reasons for their involvement rather than social or economic ones. In addition, he points out that British people who had converted to Islam were not hurt in the rebellion, whereas Indians who had converted to Christianity did suffer. While focusing primarily on events in Delhi, Dalrymple suggests that rather than a coherent mutiny or war, there were several different uprisings and acts of resistance across Hindustan (modern-day north India) which had different causes and rationales depending on location and circumstances.
Choose a historical figure, read a book about them, and create a timeline of the major events in their life.
I read Robert K. Massie’s Catherine the Great: Portrait of a Woman (Random House, 2012), a biography of the Russian empress. My timeline is below.
Identify a critical moment in history and explain its significance.
There are so many choices I could have made for this clause, but I’ve gone for the death of Arthur, Prince of Wales on 2 April 1502. He was the eldest son of Henry VII – the first Tudor king – and Elizabeth of York, and was married to Catherine of Aragon in 1501. Six months later, he died, possibly from the sweating sickness, at Ludlow Castle in Shropshire.
Arthur’s death meant that his younger brother Prince Henry became heir to the throne. He ruled as Henry VIII from 1509 to 1547. Henry married his brother’s widow, Catherine, and divorced her years later after she failed to bear him a son. One reason given for the divorce was that their marriage was invalid because Catherine had been married to Henry’s brother.
Without Henry VIII, England would not have broken with Rome, the dissolution of the monasteries would not have taken place, and the Church of England would not exist. Culturally, Henry VIII and his six wives are well known; if Arthur had reigned as king, Henry’s multiple marriages would not have happened. Six: The Musical would not exist!
The history of the sixteenth century would have looked very different. We would not have had Elizabeth I (or Mary I or Edward V). Since James VI of Scotland became James I of England after the death of Elizabeth I, who died without children, it is possible that England and Scotland might never have been united if Arthur and his heirs had ruled England.
Visit a museum or historical exhibit. Consider how they approach the subject and the choice of artefacts and exhibits. If you were tasked with creating an exhibition on the same era, event or topic, what would you change?
I visited the exhibition Legion: life in the Roman army at the British Museum. I loved the exhibition and liked how they chose a particular soldier to follow throughout his army career. I loved how they made the exhibition appeal to children through the use of a cute rat character. The items on display were incredible, including an original longshield and several grave markers, as well as tablets granting retired soldiers citizenship.
It would have been interesting to follow two soldiers, one a citizen and one not, to see how their experiences contrasted. It would also have been good to find out more about actual battles: how they played out, soldiers’ experiences and so on.
Choose a historical period, event, or topic, and study it. Read or listen to at least two books, and watch at least one film or documentary about it. Present your findings in the format of your choice – e.g. a scrapbook, video, exhibition.
Mindful of recent events, I chose to study the Israel-Palestine conflict. It’s an incredibly complex and emotive topic, and though I’ve learned a great deal I want to continue to study it. My booklet showing what I learned is below.
Date completed: 28 June 2024
One thought on “Rebel Badge Club: Historian”