When I was little I loved to read books like Enid Blyton’s Secret Seven and Five Find-Outers, and I remember having my own fingerprinting kit and my own detective club (never actually popular with anyone else). Therefore I was really looking forward to the Detective badge.
Learn about the science of fingerprinting.
Fingerprints are completely unique, even more so than DNA. Fingerprints are the tiny ridges, whorls and valley patterns on the tip of each finger. They form from pressure on a baby’s tiny, developing fingers in the womb. Fingerprint analysis has been used in criminal cases from the mid-nineteenth century. Scotland Yard established its first Fingerprint Bureau in 1901. The Japanese National Police Agency established the first electronic fingerprint matching system in the 1980s.
Fingerprints are an example of biometrics. They are relatively accessible and easy to classify and sort. They are made up of ridges called friction ridges. Each ridge contains pores, which are attached to sweat glands under the skin.
The three distinct shapes are arch, loop and whorl. Arches slope upward and then down, like narrow mountains. Loops begin on one side of the finger, curve around or upward, and exit on the other side. Whorls form a circular or spiral pattern. Looking at my own fingerprints, I appear to have whorls! Scientists analyse these patterns, including characteristics called minutiae that cannot be seen with the naked eye.
The technique of fingerprinting is known as dactyloscopy. Until digital scanning came about, it was done using ink and card. Fingerprints found at the scene of a crime can be categorised as visible prints – those that leave an impression, such as on blood, dirt or clay – or latent prints – those that can be made visible using powder, lasers or other light sources.
Learn about the use of DNA evidence.
DNA evidence has been utilised since the mid-1980s.
DNA is also known as a “genetic blueprint” as it contains the instructions that govern the development of an organism. Just 2% of human DNA contains genes that determine hair colour, eye colour and height as well as other physical features. This part is called the coding region. The other 98% is called the non-coding region, and this is used by forensic scientists in criminal investigations. It contains unique repeating patterns called short-tandem repeats (STRs) that can be measured to define the DNA profile of an individual.
All cells contain DNA except mature red blood cells. Sweat, semen, body fluids or skin cells left behind at a crime scene can be examined. No two people have completely matching STR markers, except for identical twins.
Investigators collect items from the crime scene that might have DNA on them, and analyse them. The best evidence comes when DNA from a suspect is found where it should not be. For instance, during a break-in where the suspect would not have any legitimate reason to have been there. Reference samples are taken from suspects and victims, as well as elimination samples to rule out e.g. investigators. Evidence should be properly collected and preserved in appropriate conditions.
Parents share around 50% of their DNA with their children. Siblings also share around 50% of their DNA. Grandparents/grandchildren, aunts and uncles/nieces and nephews, and half siblings share between 17% and 34%.
Learn about blood spatter analysis and different patterns.
Blood behaves according to certain scientific principles. Therefore, blood left behind at a crime scene can be analysed to work out how the blood may have been shed. Patterns, size, shape and location of the bloodstains can be analysed using principles of biology, physics and mathematics to work out where the blood came from, what caused the wounds and from what direction, the position of the victim and perpetrator and any movements made afterwards. Information can be gathered not only about what happened, but also what could not have happened, perhaps corroborating or refuting witness statements.
Bloodstains can be classified into three basic types: passive (including drops and pools), transfer (resulting from objects coming into contact with existing bloodstains) and impact (such as gushes, spurts and splashes).
Make a scrapbook about your favourite fictional detective.
I made a scrapbook about Inspector Erlendur from my favourite Icelandic detective series.
Solve at least three cases.
At the Big Rebel Meet Up last autumn I worked with my patrol to solve The Balthazar Stone.
I read The Aerial Acrobat Mystery, a solve-it-yourself detective novel.
I also listened to Cold Tapes, a podcast series investigating a murder on a remote Antarctic base.
Learn at least three different methods of concealing a message.
I completed this clause while working on the Codebreaker badge, but I will repeat my findings here. Some ways to hide a message include using invisible ink, using constrained writing (e.g. acrostics or intentional spelling mistakes), and hiding messages within digital photographs.
Watch at least three true crime documentaries, listen to at least three different true crime podcast series, or read three detective novels. Write reviews of the chosen media.
I love detective novels, so I read and reviewed three books.
I don’t read a lot of contemporary British crime. My preferences are for either classic crime of the Agatha Christie era, or modern Scandinavian crime fiction. For the Detective badge I decided to branch out and give some British crime a go. This series has been on my radar for a while as it’s set in my home region – although I’ve never actually been to Holy Island. Something I need to rectify!
This first book in the series sees our protagonist DCI Ryan enduring some enforced time off after a particularly stressful case (which we learn more about over the course of the story). The discovery of the body of a young woman, killed in a ritualistic fashion on the island of Lindisfarne, brings him back to work. Soon he and his team realise that they have a serial killer on their hands – or do they?
There was a lot to like about the book. The island setting worked well and I enjoyed the discussions of history, ritual and folklore. The plot had plenty of twists and turns and kept me guessing throughout. DCI Ryan is a likeable protagonist, even if he is a bit of a cliche – highly able but flawed, taciturn but respected by his team. Oh, and, of course, he’s hot.
Some aspects I was less keen on. The book is littered with incongruous Americanisms, though I’m inclined to blame the publisher for those. I was uncomfortable with the casual misogyny – on first meeting Anna Taylor, another major character, Ryan refuses to believe she is an academic doctor – the book is set in 2015 by the way, not 1915. The comparative descriptions of Anna and her sister made me feel uneasy. Anna herself is also hot (of course), and has seemingly gone from study at Durham University straight to an academic career at the same place without any stressful moves or fixed-term contracts, which, from what I know about academic careers these days, seems highly unlikely. I could have done without the romance, which had me rolling my eyes, and the plot, while compelling, was extremely far-fetched.
All things considered, and admittedly against my better judgement, I did enjoy this book despite its flaws. I’ll probably read the rest of the series, if only to spot locations I’m familiar with.
Tokyo Express – Seichō Matsumoto
For my second book for the Detective badge I went for Tokyo Express by Seichō Matsumoto. I’ve seen it in bookshops and thought it looked intriguing, so now was the time to give it a go.
Originally published in 1958, it is the mystery of a young couple found dead on a rocky beach. They have both died by cyanide, and it is assumed that it is a lovers’ suicide. However, two detectives – experienced Torigai Jutaro and young Kiichi Mihara from Tokyo – believe that something is not right. Between them they work to solve the puzzle of this case.
The story is unusual in that we have no real doubt of the killer’s identity – the interest is in how the detectives manage to work it out. I have come across this in other Japanese detective fiction I have read – perhaps inspired by this book, considered a classic. There are still surprises in store, motivations to uncover, and the puzzle of “howdunit”. One thing that struck me is that the plot could not have taken place in the UK – our public transport is simply too unreliable.
I liked the relationship between the two detectives, Torigai and Mihara, as there is a sense of mutual respect, particularly from the younger to the older. The tone of the book is elegiac, reminiscent of Georges Simenon novels. There is an unhurried atmosphere, yet this does not make the book any less compelling.
I appreciated the occasional diagrams showing platform layouts and train times, as they helped me to visualise what was being talked about. Similar descriptions in other novels often leave me lost without these visual aids.
I found the book very satisfying, and enjoyed the writing style. I would certainly read more by this author. I’ve never read a Japanese crime novel I didn’t like – perhaps this is because only the best are translated into English, but either way, it bodes well.
The third book I chose as part of my Detective Badge was Death On Ice by R. O. Thorp. I chose it because I’m a sucker for anything set in the Arctic. The blurb promised a cosy mystery on a cruise ship filled with scientists, crew members and rich eccentric guests – great stuff.
This is the first book in what will be a series featuring the Blanchard twins, Finn and Rose. Both scientists, they are on the ship to study Greenland sharks. When a murderer strikes, they are the only individuals free from suspicion – since they are in a submersible exploring the Arctic Ocean at the time – so end up helping two British policemen currently in Svalbard, Tom and Titus, investigate.
The Arctic setting is a great one because of the isolation, the cold and the simple inhospitableness. Rose and Finn are both appealing characters, with a close relationship that is lovely to see. I also enjoyed the relationship between the two detectives and how the four of them all worked together.
Thorp has a quirky writing style that I love, with a turn of phrase that reminded me of Wodehouse. ‘Cosy crime’ is an apt description, because even when bad things are happening, the writing made me smile. The wider cast of characters – the ship’s captain and crew, the assorted guests – are all really well drawn.
Without getting into spoiler territory, I really enjoyed the LBTQIA+ representation in the book. I wasn’t aware of this before going in, but it’s another point in the book’s favour.
I might have chosen the book because of the setting, but I definitely want to keep up with the series – I’m looking forward to the next book about this duo.
Date completed: 28 February 2025















